Every NFL week produces highlights, but only a handful of weeks produce new names. Week 5 opened with one of the season's biggest upsets: the previously winless Tampa Bay Buccaneers walked into AT&T Stadium on Thursday night and beat the Dallas Cowboys 24-16, and they did it with an undrafted rookie making his second career start and a running back who refused to be tackled. By Friday morning, the story of the week was no longer the teams at the top of the standings — it was the players who refused to wait for their turn.
This is the spotlight board for that wave. Below you will find the moments that defined the week, the stat lines that back them up, and the return-or-out picture for Sunday's slate. If you want the standings context first, our Week 4 recap covers CeeDee Lamb's 17-catch game and the Rams' comeback in Philadelphia, and the trade wire tracks every move feeding into these rosters.
The Week 5 Breakout Board, in One Table
Six players defined the week that was. Four of them entered it as afterthoughts in their own buildings; one is a former first-round pick cashing in a fresh start; the last is a star whose workload is now a weekly conversation. Every number below comes from the week's box scores and team reports.
Jalon Daniels: An Undrafted Rookie Steals Prime Time in Dallas
Start with the quarterback nobody drafted. With Baker Mayfield sidelined by a dislocated thumb on his throwing hand, the Buccaneers handed the offense to Jalon Daniels, the undrafted rookie out of Kansas making only his second NFL start. He finished 19-of-25 for 189 yards and a touchdown without a turnover, added 23 rushing yards, and posted a 110.2 passer rating in a 24-16 road win that moved Tampa Bay to 1-4 and dropped Dallas to 2-3.
The opening drive was the signature. Daniels went a perfect 8-for-8 on a 15-play, 73-yard march that consumed 10 minutes 58 seconds and ended with a 5-yard touchdown pass to Bucky Irving — the longest scoring drive by elapsed time in franchise history since at least 2001, per team notes. By the end of the night he had directed 419 total net yards, controlled possession for 39:21 and become, per the club's research notes, the first undrafted rookie quarterback to ever beat the Cowboys, and the third since 1950 to win in prime time within his first two starts.
Credit the plan around him, too. Todd Bowles sent safety Tykee Smith after Dak Prescott again and again — five pressures on seven blitzes, per ESPN — and Prescott completed just 2 of 13 throws against the blitz through three quarters. Dallas finished with three turnovers, including the game-sealing interception by Alex Anzalone off a tipped pass in the final two minutes, and managed 50 rushing yards. For a Buccaneers team that entered the night 0-4 with its quarterback out, it was the complete next-man-up performance — and the reason the Tampa Bay Buccaneers collection is suddenly worth a second look. Mayfield is expected to miss at least one more game, which means Daniels gets at least one more chance to keep the job warm, or take it.
Bucky Irving Turns One Snap Into a 165-Yard Statement
Irving's night is the easiest highlight to explain. On the first play of the second half, with Tampa Bay trailing 10-7, he burst through the right side for a 72-yard run — the longest of his career — and one play later Emeka Egbuka scored on a 14-yard jet sweep. The Buccaneers never trailed again, piling up 17 points in the third quarter and 241 rushing yards as a team.
The final line: 21 carries, a career-high 165 yards at 7.9 per attempt, a 5-yard receiving touchdown, a 1-yard plunge, and 175 yards from scrimmage. It was his fourth career 100-yard game, his first with both a rushing and a receiving score, and it pushed him past 2,000 career rushing yards in his 32nd game — tying Warrick Dunn for the fourth-fewest games to reach that mark in franchise history. Per the AP's game notes, his 165 yards were the most by any player against Dallas in a Cowboys home game since 2012. He also finished the night the way closers do, ripping off a 22-yard run on the possession that let Tampa Bay kneel it out.
The larger point for October: the Buccaneers' 31.24 defensive EPA through four weeks ranked third in the NFL, and everyone knew the defense would keep them in games. What nobody knew was whether the offense could win one. Irving answered that on one snap, and Dallas's own defensive numbers — last in the league in EPA per pass play allowed and passer rating allowed — suggest that fixing that side of the ball will be the focus in Dallas before the November deadline.
Deonte Banks Called His Shot, Then Ran 98 Yards
The best defensive moment of the week actually came in Week 4, when the Giants beat Arizona 36-24 to climb to 3-1 and the top of the NFC East. On the game's final snap, with the Cardinals at the goal line needing a touchdown, cornerback Deonte Banks jumped a route, picked off Jacoby Brissett on fourth-and-goal and returned it 98 yards for a touchdown as time expired. He finished with four passes defensed, tied for the most by any player in a game this season, and on Wednesday the league named him NFC Defensive Player of the Week — the first Giants cornerback to win it since 2019.
The backstory is what makes it a breakout rather than a fluke. Banks, a 2023 first-round pick, missed the first two games of this season with a calf injury and had weathered two difficult years before the new staff arrived. Rather than reset him with a lecture, coach John Harbaugh made it simple. "We just made it about the football," Harbaugh told reporters on Monday. Banks made it about the football, all right — he told teammates he had been calling the slant all week. "I knew I was going to take it," he said after the game. "I've been calling it all week."
He was not the only Giant having a week. Malik Nabers caught six passes for 112 yards and a touchdown in that Arizona win, his best game of the season and his first score of the year, before a knee issue landed him on the midweek report. Now comes the test: the 3-1 Giants visit a 1-3 Washington team that expects to get quarterback Jayden Daniels back, with first place in the division on the line. Fans riding the surge can find the whole wall in the New York Giants collection.
The Return Board: Who Is Back and Who Is Out in Week 5
Breakouts do not happen in a vacuum — they happen because someone else is in the training room. Week 5's availability board is one of the busiest of the season, and it reshapes Sunday's slate from London to New Orleans. Here is where the biggest names stand, based on the midweek reports.
Two names on that board carry extra weight this Sunday. Daniels returning gives Washington its opening-day quarterback back just as the Giants arrive — and gives Banks a whole new set of problems, since Washington's passing game leans on Stefon Diggs (18 catches, three touchdowns) and a healthy Daniels extension game. And Jefferson's likely return in New Orleans, the stadium where he won a college national championship, could unlock a Minnesota offense that has scored one touchdown in a month. The 4-0 Vikings are already the strangest story in the league, as our surprise teams breakdown documented; adding their best player back into a perfect record is how October narratives get made. Commanders fans can browse the Washington Commanders collection ahead of the divisional showdown.
What the Breakout Wave Says About the Rest of October
Zoom out and the pattern is hard to miss: depth is winning. The Buccaneers won without their quarterback. The Bears are 3-1 while rotating starters under center. The Giants just won a game on a play made by a corner fighting his way back from an injury and a coaching change. Even Dallas's miserable Thursday — a game in which newly acquired corner Joey Porter Jr. was a late scratch — doubles as an argument that the margin between 3-2 and 2-3 in this league is one healthy body and one prepared backup.
The NFC East race is the clearest beneficiary. The Giants lead it at 3-1, the Eagles have dropped two straight with their defensive centerpiece playing on one arm and their running back out in London, the Cowboys just lost at home to a winless team, and the Commanders get their quarterback back with the division leader coming to town. Four teams, one section of the standings, and every single one of them enters Week 5 with a different answer to the same question.
For fans, breakout weeks are also roster-decision weeks. The jersey you buy in October is a bet on who a player is becoming, not just what he did last year. A career year from Irving, a turnaround season from Banks and a first winning start from Daniels are exactly the kinds of arcs that fill stadiums by December. Our 2026 jersey buying guide breaks down the fit and tier differences before you commit to a name on the back, and the Cowboys and Buccaneers walls are the fastest way to shop Thursday night's winners.
NFL Breakouts FAQ
Who is Jalon Daniels and how did an undrafted rookie beat the Cowboys?
Daniels is an undrafted rookie quarterback out of Kansas starting for the injured Baker Mayfield. In his second career start he went 19-of-25 for 189 yards and a touchdown with no turnovers and a 110.2 rating, led a 10:58 opening touchdown drive in which he completed all eight of his passes, and directed 419 total yards in Tampa Bay's 24-16 win in Dallas. Per team research notes, he is the first undrafted rookie quarterback to defeat the Cowboys.
How big was Bucky Irving's night against Dallas?
Career-high big. Irving ran 21 times for 165 yards and a touchdown, caught a 5-yard score, and broke a 72-yard run on the first snap of the second half that flipped the game for good. It was his fourth career 100-yard game, his first with a rushing and receiving touchdown in the same game, and it pushed him past 2,000 career rushing yards in just his 32nd game.
What did Deonte Banks do to win NFC Defensive Player of the Week?
With the Giants leading Arizona by six on the final snap of a 36-24 win, Banks intercepted Jacoby Brissett on fourth-and-goal and returned it 98 yards for a touchdown as time expired. He added four passes defensed, tied for the most in a game by any player this season, and became the first Giants cornerback to win the weekly award since 2019 — in his first game back after missing two with a calf injury.
Which big names are returning or out for the rest of Week 5?
Jayden Daniels is on track to return for the Commanders against the Giants, and Justin Jefferson is questionable and hopeful for the unbeaten Vikings in New Orleans. Out: Lamar Jackson (ankle) for the Ravens against Atlanta and Saquon Barkley (hamstring) for the Eagles in London. Caleb Williams is questionable with a hamstring strain, Ja'Marr Chase is in the concussion protocol, Jalen Carter is playing through a wrist cast, and CeeDee Lamb is nursing a quad injury.
Shop the Jerseys in This Story
Picks from the breakout teams and players covered above. Every card opens the product page directly.
